Subscribe to TSC Wrestling with Fred Richani on YouTube for more wrestling interviews, news and reviews!

Listen here or download the MP3.

Fred Richani recaps NXT TakeOver: Toronto on Nov. 19, 2016, during Survivor Series weekend, with three titles on the line, two title changes and a Dusty Rhodes Tag Team Classic winner.

NXT TakeOver: Toronto Review

Adapted from the episode and edited for clarity and brevity. Listen above for the full review.

Samoa Joe pinned Shinsuke Nakamura clean with the Muscle Buster to regain the NXT Championship and become the first two-time NXT champion. Much like their Brooklyn match, which I attended live, it was very good, maybe even better, with a hot and respectful Toronto crowd, but something seemed to be missing, as it has in a lot of Joe’s big NXT matches. He looked a little slow and wore a knee brace, but he brought as much as he could at 38. Joe winning could mean Nakamura debuts at the Royal Rumble, and for the love of God, put him on SmackDown. He’d get lost in three hours of Raw.

Bobby Roode, with a choir singing “Glorious,” beat Tye Dillinger in the opener. Dillinger’s gimmick connects with fans, and he’d be great for main roster house shows, but at 35, he either gets called up or becomes a coach. I think Roode is a major league player still waiting for his blowaway NXT match. The Authors of Pain beat TM-61 in the Dusty Rhodes Tag Team Classic final with Paul Ellering hanging above the ring in a cage. The Authors of Pain are in their early 20s, so maybe a year from now we’ll call them the authors of awesome. Triple H, meanwhile, finally showed up to work 10 weeks after helping Kevin Owens win the Universal title.

The best match of the night, maybe the NXT match of the year, was DIY’s Johnny Gargano and Tommaso Ciampa beating The Revival two falls to one for the NXT tag team titles. In the final fall, both members of The Revival held hands, refusing to tap, and then tapped out at the same time. The crowd went nuts. I loved their Brooklyn match live, and this was even better. These four men are on another level, and I hope we see them on the main roster soon.

Asuka beat Mickie James with a quick submission that came out of nowhere. Mickie made Asuka sell and look somewhat vulnerable, but then Asuka raised the title and walked away without a handshake. As one tweet put it, I didn’t sign up for another Charlotte. Somebody has to beat her eventually. Overall, a really good show with a hot crowd, though the women’s and NXT title matches underwhelmed a bit. With Nakamura and The Revival likely headed up, NXT needs to build up younger talent like Ember Moon, Liv Morgan, Roderick Strong and No Way Jose.

Podcast Transcript

This podcast transcript has been edited for clarity. Watch or listen above for the full show.

Read the full podcast transcript

What’s up, everybody? This is Fred Richani of TSC News, here to recap WWE NXT TakeOver: Toronto, November 19th, 2016. We had three titles on the line. We had two title changes. We have a new NXT Dusty Rhodes Tag Team Classic winner, or winners. We have new NXT Tag Team Champions, and we have a new NXT World Champion. That’s right: in the main event, Samoa Joe pinned Shinsuke Nakamura clean in the middle of the damn ring with a Muscle Buster to regain the NXT Championship and become the first-ever two-time NXT Champion.

Now, I’ve got to say, much like their match in Brooklyn, which I was live for, I felt like there was something missing in this match. It was not a bad match at all. In fact, I’d say it was a very good match, and perhaps even better than their Brooklyn match. I feel like the crowd here in Toronto was pretty hot, very respectful. There were a few annoying chants throughout the night, but at the end of the day, a lively crowd is better than a dead crowd, and I thought they really enhanced this match. But something seemed to be missing, much like it has in a lot of Samoa Joe’s big NXT matches, and in a lot of the Nakamura-Samoa Joe matches. I really don’t know what it is.

I did get a DM from a good friend of mine that’s pretty well connected, that used to be with WWE, who straight up said, “Listen, Samoa Joe: great character, great promo, but in the ring he’s clearly slowed down.” And if you watch him tonight, he did look a little slow. Obviously he’s never had the best body. He did have the knee brace on. He was kind of dragging himself a little bit. I still think he brought it. He brought as much as he could for a 38-year-old man.

But it’s interesting, because you would think that since Samoa Joe is older, he’d be called up to the main roster rather than win the NXT title. But this person made the point to me that said, “You know what? I don’t get why people feel like Samoa Joe, at age 38, with all the mileage on his body, can just go right to the main roster and handle a main roster schedule.” And I thought about it, and I tried to think about it not from a selfish standpoint, because selfishly I’d love to see him there. We have mutual friends. He’s a nice guy. He’s obviously one of the best wrestlers of the last decade, and a guy that deserves to make the big, big, big main roster bucks.

But perhaps the reason he’s in NXT is not just because of the fact that he was originally signed just to be in NXT. Perhaps it’s because Triple H, Regal, a lot of those guys there think, “You know what? His body probably can’t handle a full-time schedule.” I don’t know if that’s the case, but that was what was DM’d to me, and this is a person who I respect very much, who’s very well connected, who’s usually on point with a lot of his observations, so I’ll take their word for it.

But either way, I’m happy for Samoa Joe. He’s still doing well. He’s getting that merch money, he’s getting that NXT money, he’s in the video game for the second straight year, which is pretty cool. And Nakamura losing the title at an interesting time. Could that mean Shinsuke Nakamura debuts at the Royal Rumble? Could that mean that they slide him into the SmackDown brand? And for the love of God, I think he should be on the SmackDown brand. While Raw could use a Nakamura, while any brand could use a Nakamura, I feel like he’d just get lost in the shuffle of those three long, agonizing hours.

This show was about two and a half hours. Not agonizing at all. A little dull at times, but not agonizing at all. So we had Samoa Joe win the NXT Championship. The crowd was stunned, I was kind of stunned, but hopefully that means Nakamura is on to the main roster.

We opened the show with Bobby Roode getting a choir singing “Glorious,” and Bobby Roode ended up defeating Tye Dillinger. Not a bad match, but I’m wondering what the hell Tye Dillinger is still doing in NXT. I get that he’s a lifetime good hand, a guy that maybe has been a great prospect for many years but never above that. But he has a really good gimmick. He has a connection with the crowd. I really do feel like his gimmick could connect with the crowd on the main roster. It’d be great for house shows especially, so I would like to see him called up.

I don’t think that’s going to happen. I feel like he’s a lifetime NXT guy, a lifetime FCW, OVW guy. I hope I’m wrong about that, but the poor guy is 35 years old already. I mean, his ceiling’s right here. At some point they’ve either got to call him up or hire him as a coach. He would be a really good coach. But I don’t get it. At least use him on the house shows. Lord knows your main roster house shows could use more entertainment, and he’s an entertaining guy.

As for Bobby Roode, I think he’s a major league player. Some people find him boring. I don’t think he’s had that blow-away match in NXT yet. I’m still waiting for it. Maybe it’ll happen, maybe it won’t.

I’m a little surprised here, because I would think that Samoa Joe would have lost tonight. Shinsuke would retain, hold the title for a little bit longer, have Bobby Roode win the title, and then Nakamura can go up. Now that Samoa Joe’s won, you would think that unless they’re going to turn Samoa Joe babyface, that would mean that a babyface is going to challenge Samoa Joe. Now, it could be Nakamura again. I really don’t want to see another never-ending Samoa Joe feud, like you had the never-ending one with Finn Bálor. You could have Nakamura challenge him again.

Or actually, I really don’t know who. I’m looking at this roster tonight, I’m looking up and down: who would challenge Samoa Joe? Eric Young? I don’t think one of the DIY guys is going to challenge him. I mean, maybe he is turning face, who knows? Who knows? Maybe they’re just going to do Nakamura versus Samoa Joe over and over again. Or, you know what, maybe, just maybe, they’ll make things interesting. They’ll sweeten the pot for the third time around, and they will do Samoa Joe versus Nakamura, loser leaves NXT. Although I’ve got to say this, though: whoever leaves NXT is leaving for greener pastures, maybe not creatively, but money-wise, exposure-wise. So is that really much of a stipulation? Who knows? Who knows? But we’ll see what happens.

But anyway, Bobby Roode got the win in the opener. We had TM61 against the Authors of Pain. I skipped the last few weeks of NXT. There’s just been a lot going on. I’ve been keeping up, but I haven’t really been sitting down and watching NXT. A lot of wrestling on lately, a lot going on. I work in advertising; it’s a very, very busy time of the year. So I’ve been keeping up, reading up on NXT, but I was pleas… well, I don’t know if pleasantly surprised is the right phrase. Uniquely surprised to see that Paul Ellering was being hung up in a cage all the way at the top, which is kind of creepy and kind of weird, and I guess if you’re into that kind of stuff, I’m not going to judge. But apparently it was a match stipulation, not a fetish. So he was locked up in the cage. I think they had this stipulation with Chyna many years ago. I can’t remember; it might have been an In Your House pay-per-view from years back in the Attitude Era.

But anyway, TM61 and the Authors of Pain, or as I occasionally like to call them, the Authors of Lame, wrestled in the Dusty Rhodes Classic final. Authors of Pain got the win. TM61 worked really, really hard, but there’s just something missing with these guys. TM61, they were good in NOAH. I’m willing to cut them some slack. I hope they can get over, but right now they’re just kind of flailing. And in terms of the Authors of Pain, the bright side is that these two dudes are in their early 20s. So if they’re willing to learn, if they’re willing to apply themselves and get better, who knows? Maybe a year from now we’ll be talking about the Authors of Pain as the Authors of Awesome. But right now, not so much.

Also, Triple H finally decided to show up to work, 10 weeks later after helping Kevin Owens win the title, and he presented them with the trophy. So is Triple H going to be on Raw or SmackDown anytime soon? I doubt it. I doubt it. Royal Rumble time, when football season’s over and ratings magically go up, probably. Probably. Unless, of course, they do a bit of a swerve, and rather than doing Brock Lesnar versus Shane McMahon, which has been rumored for months now, which would be freaking horrible…

You could actually do a more interesting match with Shane McMahon, even though I don’t want to see Shane McMahon wrestle again. You could have Shane McMahon versus Triple H at WrestleMania, and that way it’d be two guys that are practically non-wrestlers at this point that could have a decent match. They won’t be taken away from another guy. They won’t have to beat a guy that’s on the main roster all the time. And it would play into the real beef. I mean, I feel like there’s some real beef between Shane McMahon and Triple H. I don’t think either of them have been in the same segment since Shane McMahon’s comeback. Who knows? Maybe they wouldn’t want to put their differences aside, maybe they would. I feel like that’d be a more interesting story at this point than Rollins versus Triple H. I feel like it could be a lot better than Brock Lesnar having to sell for Shane McMahon. My goodness gracious.

Oh, and for those that don’t know, Survivor Series is tomorrow, or today, depending on when you’re listening to this podcast. And yes, we will have an in-depth recap of all that.

And then we had the best match on the show, maybe the NXT match of the year, maybe the WWE match of the year. We had DIY, Gargano and Ciampa, taking on The Revival. This was a two-out-of-three falls match. The Revival got the first fall with the Shatter Machine. Then it was Gargano with the second fall. And then lastly, it was Ciampa and Gargano locking in the submissions. Both members of The Revival didn’t want to tap. They held each other’s hands; it was so cute. They wanted to stop themselves from tapping, and Dawson says, “Don’t tap,” and Dash says, “Don’t tap,” and what do you know, both tapped out at the same time. The crowd went nuts.

This little recap doesn’t do it justice. If you want to watch any of the matches that took place tonight, go out of your way to watch this match. I was there live for the Brooklyn match. It was great. This was even better, if you can believe that. It was excellent. Excellent. So go out of your way to watch The Revival versus DIY for the NXT Tag titles. This was a classic. I know that “You deserve it” chant is so old and overdone and has jumped the shark, but my God, these four men deserve the spotlight they got tonight. They are on another level. I’m sorry, there’s a lot of really good main roster cats out there, but these dudes, especially together as teams, are on another level, and I hope we see them on the main roster soon. Just excellent. Excellent.

And then we had Asuka versus Mickie James. Pretty good match. Asuka got the win with a quick submission at the end. This just came out of nowhere. The good thing was that Mickie James actually made Asuka sell a bit, and it was nice to see Asuka actually look somewhat vulnerable. I feel like her selling was better in this match than it has been in past matches. A lot of times I get the feeling she’s kind of like the female Roman Reigns in some ways, only more popular and better looking. She just sells sometimes and it’s not really believable, because she’s such a monster. This was a little bit better. The crowd was behind Mickie, and then she just won out of nowhere. It was kind of lame, if you ask me. I was kind of hoping we’d see a more back-and-forth match.

My friend Candace here, I’ll just read you what she said. She was just like, “What the hell? Mickie is a damn legend. I was ready to see Mickie win. Why didn’t Mickie win?” Yeah, I don’t know. I don’t know. I mean, look, Asuka won with the Asuka Lock. It is what it is. And then Asuka was going to shake Mickie’s hand, or was shaking Mickie’s hand, and then she takes the title belt and just raises it over her shoulder, doesn’t even shake hands, and walks away.

And I saw a great tweet from Rover online who kind of summed up my thoughts, and it was, “I didn’t sign up for another Charlotte.” Yeah, it’s starting to feel that way. And I like Charlotte a lot, and I actually think Charlotte right now is a better character than Asuka, but they’re both kind of at that point where they’re winning so much, so many times, at times in kind of buzzkill fashion, it’s almost like, “All right, what’s next?” Right? Like, I think Sasha should definitely have won the title at Hell in a Cell.

I’m not saying Mickie should have won against Asuka, but at some point somebody’s got to beat this chick. Who’s it going to be? I don’t really know. I would like to see maybe somebody that they’re not doing anything with on the main roster come down to NXT and make something happen. Maybe Natalya. Although I know Natalya is really popular and she’s on Total Divas, but maybe, just maybe, you can have Natalya come down, challenge Asuka like she did in Japan on the house shows, and maybe win the title and kind of promote NXT on the main roster. You could do that. I don’t think it’s going to happen, but you could do that.

So overall, really good show, really hot crowd. I do think the women’s match and the world title match kind of underwhelmed a little bit, just a little bit. But that tag title match, man, my God, awesome. But now we’re wondering, where the hell does NXT go from here? Nakamura, perhaps main roster bound. The Revival, perhaps main roster bound. Everybody else, good luck figuring out what the hell is going to happen. Hopefully, hopefully, they hit somewhat of a reset button and try to build up these younger guys. I mean, you’ve got Ember Moon, who’s really good. You’ve got Liv Morgan. I know she got destroyed a few weeks back against Asuka, but she’s got potential. Leah’s got potential. They need to do something.

SAnitY, not really feeling SAnitY. It’s hard for me to get excited for Eric Young in 2016 going into 2017, but who knows? They’ve got Roderick Strong. Maybe they fast-track Roderick Strong to a title shot. Maybe he beats Samoa Joe. I think those guys could have one hell of a match, although Roderick Strong is still technically kind of sort of new, not necessarily to the NXT audience, which is a lot of hardcore fans, but mainly to the WWE audience. I think once Austin Aries comes back, it’s going to enhance these guys.

And look out for No Way Jose. I think No Way Jose can do pretty well. He’s a bigger guy than people expect. He’s not terrible in the ring. I feel like the gimmick is really one-dimensional, even though it’s a great, fun gimmick for the house shows and stuff like that, and the crowd likes to dance. But I think behind that gimmick there is some real talent there in that kid, so hopefully they can harness that talent and make something happen. And hopefully for the likes of TM61, who had great success in Japan, hopefully they can eventually get it together, not just in the ring, but character-wise as well.

In the meantime, Samoa Joe’s your champ. The Authors of Pain are most likely going to destroy DIY, or maybe they’ll lose and then destroy them eventually. Asuka, AKA Charlotte, is still your champion in the women’s division, and we shall see what happens.

But folks, I want to hear from you. What do you think about NXT TakeOver? What do you think about Survivor Series? Let me know. Leave a comment below, tweet us, Facebook us, do what you’ve got to do. If you enjoyed this recap, please like, share, take care, subscribe on YouTube, iTunes, SoundCloud, you name it, we’ve got it. Until next time, as always, enjoy the matches.


Discover more from Fred Richani's TSC News

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply